

Prosecutors say they have thousands of pages of evidence

Somehow, as investigators fought with one another, a key piece of information in the case - a witnesses’s description of Heuermann’s pickup truck - got lost in the shuffle, only to resurface recently.

The tension grew so high that, at Sini’s urging, the case’s longtime lead detective was removed. Detectives, meanwhile, felt that the district attorney at the time, Tim Sini, was forcing them to investigate leads they had already ruled out while ratcheting up pressure to solve the case before his 2021 reelection bid. Prosecutors believed the detectives refused to follow orders and clashed with federal partners, multiple high-level law enforcement officials familiar with the case said. The Washington Post published an article on Tuesday detailing how years of conflict between various factions working on the Gilgo Beach killings led to a lengthy delay in solving the case: Infighting led to bungling of the Heuermann case No charges associated with her disappearance or death have been filed. Vergata was identified using DNA evidence. Newsday reports police do not believe there is a link between Vergata’s death and alleged Gilgo Beach killer Rex Heuermann, according to source. 7” and “Fire Island Jane Doe” was Karen Vergata, who was 36 years old and is believed to have been working as an escort when she went missing in 1996. Suffolk County district attorney Ray Tierney announced on Friday that the woman who investigators had been calling “Jane Doe No. Police on Long Island have determined the identity of a woman whose partial remains were found both on Fire Island in 1996 and near Jones Beach in 2011.

Gilgo Beach investigators have identified “Jane Doe No.
